Monograph Series · Third series › Part I Framing the claim and access to court › III-06 · First edition
The Time of Rights: Prescription and Filing Periods as Different Thresholds
Can a remedy be barred because the time for proceedings has run, even though the right itself survives?
Volume contents
Abstract
This volume asks whether relief can be barred because the time for proceedings has run, even though the right itself survives. The time at which a right becomes exercisable, the interruption of prescription, peremptory periods, and subsequent completion are distinct institutions. An expiry date without the facts establishing the starting point is not a conclusion. The path to relief opens where the facts establishing the starting point and the period under the applicable rule are connected with grounds for interruption or subsequent completion so that the exercise of the right in question is permitted, and closes where the relevant period has passed and the requirements for relief applicable to that proceeding, such as interruption or subsequent completion, are also not satisfied. The six sections address, in turn, the different kinds of time, when a right can be exercised, the statutory grounds for interruption, failed judicial claims, impediments for subsequent completion, and the facts that precede writing a date. The strongest counterargument is as follows. The strictness of periods may shift onto the right holder even impediments that the right holder could not control. Integrated schedule management and the reconstruction of times from the original records are not addressed in this volume.
Synthetic case
The whole volume follows this invented case. It is not a real matter, and its facts are not legal findings.
Plaintiff A states that A sought to exercise the right, and Defendant B asserts that it was too late, but service and the time at which the right became exercisable are in dispute.
6 sections and their questions
- 01The Different Kinds of Time
Can prescription and peremptory periods be handled by the same calculation?
21 min - 02When a Right Can Be Exercised
Is the date on which the right holder became aware always the start of prescription?
20 min - 03The Statutory Grounds for Interruption
Does the mere fact of having responded stop prescription?
19 min - 04Failed Judicial Claims
What becomes of the interruptive effect if the suit is dismissed or withdrawn?
18 min - 05Impediments to Subsequent Completion
When does a cause not attributable to the party reopen the proceedings?
20 min - 06The Facts Before Writing a Date
What must first be established before an expiry date can be written?
19 min